Marangoni, Daniel (2018). A quantum model of human subjectivity for moral psychology: Using Q methodology to define features of judgments in Hilbert space. Doctoral dissertation (Educational Psychology), Oklahoma State University.

Abstract: A major issue in the field of moral psychology is identifying aspects of human morality that can be measured. Kantor’s (1959) formulation of a psychological event provides a unique option for the field. A psychological event evolves over time through the interaction of current situations and stimuli with historical interbehavioral processes. Kantor’s formulation of a psychological event has these elements interacting within the psychological field under review, but the space is undefined. Stephenson (1982) offers Q methodology as a research tool to measure psychological events and does so by defining the psychological field within Hilbert space—a generalized Euclidean space where belief states of individuals are represented as vectors within the space. Using the well-known Julie and Mark vignette (Haidt, 2001) about a sister and brother who decide to make love, this study investigates the viewpoints of participants, who are experts in moral philosophy and psychology, regarding the story. In previous studies with the Julie and Mark vignette, participants were unable to articulate their beliefs about the event: this has led to the conclusion that people have intuitive moral reactions, but they often exhibit dumbfounding when they attempt to explain their intuitive reactions (Haidt, 2001). This Q methodology study operationalized the subjective perspectives of participants in order to define their viewpoints. The stable viewpoints are defined with the data and show unique ways of framing the story and are Personal Autonomy, Human Nature, Outcomes, and Individuals in Context. The interpretation of the findings defines these viewpoints and shows how they differ when the vignette is considered from different perspectives. By setting the psychological field within Hilbert space where quantum theory explicitly applies (Stephenson, 1982), the viewpoints can be used to define the features of belief projections as explained by the important work in quantum cognition and decision making. By defining participants’ viewpoints, this study shows that people are not dumbfounded about their moral beliefs.

Daniel Marangoni <> is director of research operations, Office of Research, Center for Health Sciences, Oklahoma State University, Tulsa, OK (USA).

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s